Kirk Herbstreit's viral dog-steak video draws a 'what's likable about him?' blast

Celebrity & Entertainment journalist
Kirk Herbstreit, ESPN college football analyst
Kirk Herbstreit Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 3.0

Kirk Herbstreit has spent years as one of the most recognizable faces in college football media. But a viral clip of his dog Peter being fed steak at a New York City steakhouse has people asking a sharper question: is the ESPN analyst actually likable?

On the latest episode of Mostly Sports, Barstool Sports' Mark Titus went there. "I don't know if he is likable anymore. It's not even the dog thing," Titus said. "I think Kirk Herbstreit is likable because we were told he's likable, because he was just like vanilla. He was just there. And then upon further scrutiny, we're like, what's likable about him?"

The steakhouse video was posted Thursday by Herbstreit's content team, showing Peter - a regular on College GameDay and Thursday Night Football - being fed at a New York steakhouse. The clip did not land well with everyone.

Craig Carton was blunt about it on his own show. "I'm not anti-dog. I just don't want to go to a steakhouse and eat next to a dog. Because it's disgusting," Carton said.

It is not the first time Carton has gone after Herbstreit over his dogs. Last year he said "we don't care about your freaking dog," mocking Herbstreit for flying Peter on a private jet and getting a new dog soon after his beloved golden retriever Ben died.

The dog content keeps backfiring

On Monday's Mostly Sports, co-host Brandon Walker was gentler - he called Herbstreit likable but took a shot at the constant dog content. "You're so goddamn likable on your own. I don't know when the PR team said you have to have a dog on you at all times and then your dog died and you immediately brought in a replacement dog," Walker said.

Titus was less convinced the likability even exists. His take frames Herbstreit's reputation as more reflex than fact - an assumption inherited from years of being a steady, uncontroversial presence on ESPN.

Given the reaction, the ESPN star might want to leave Peter at home the next time he goes out to dinner.

More in the section Sport

Patrick Mahomes preparing to snap the ball for the Kansas City Chiefs
Sport

Patrick Mahomes threw 5 TDs on a UCL elbow injury - Rex Ryan is in awe

Patrick Mahomes threw for 348 yards and five touchdowns on an elbow with a minor UCL injury, and Rex Ryan says that toughness might be his best trait.

Christian Pulisic in a US men's national team jersey during a match against Belgium
Sport

Pulisic and Balogun both score in 6-0 US rout of Haiti as Pochettino nears exit

Christian Pulisic and Folarin Balogun both scored in their U.S. return as the Americans routed Haiti 6-0 in Miami, kicking off Mauricio Pochettino's brief farewell.

Miami Hurricanes basketball players in action during a game
Sport

Brent Bland hits 8 threes off the bench as No. 17 Miami sets a school 3-point record

The fifth-year transfer buried a career-high eight 3s in 20 minutes as the Hurricanes drained 20 of 47 from deep against North Alabama.

Pat Cummins fielding for Australia in a Test match
Sport

Pat Cummins calls Khawaja's Sandpapergate claims '100 per cent wrong' and 'utter nonsense'

Australia's captain broke his silence on claims in Usman Khawaja's new book that the whole 2018 team knew about sandpaper.

Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes smiling on the field
Sport

Patrick Mahomes and Brittany announce baby No. 4 - the NFL's reaction is one word

Patrick and Brittany Mahomes revealed on Instagram that they are expecting their fourth child, and the NFL's comment was a single word.

Lewis Hamilton in Ferrari race overalls during 2025 Italian Grand Prix qualifying
Sport

Lewis Hamilton is catching Mercedes' flight home - Toto Wolff has a drink planned

Lewis Hamilton will board Mercedes' flight home from Interlagos after their constructors' title, with Toto Wolff teasing a shared drink.

Houston Texans wide receiver Tank Dell
Sport

Tank Dell scores first TD in 687 days as Texans receiver completes comeback from torn knee

Tank Dell found the end zone for the first time since Dec. 21, 2024, hauling in a 63-yard touchdown in just his second game back.

Lionel Messi of Inter Miami in action during an MLS match
Sport

Messi sets up two as Inter Miami blow 3-0 lead but seal second in MLS

Inter Miami drew 3-3 with Charlotte but held on to second in the Eastern Conference, booking a playoff opener against the Columbus Crew.

Doc Rivers coaching from the sideline during a game
Sport

Doc Rivers says Giannis 'doesn't have super IQ' and never wanted to be the bad guy

Doc Rivers called coaching Giannis Antetokounmpo difficult and says the two-time MVP 'doesn't necessarily have super IQ' - he needs to learn execution.

CeeDee Lamb in Dallas Cowboys uniform during a game
Sport

CeeDee Lamb blasts Cowboys offense: 'We stop ourselves. That sh*t is frustrating'

The Cowboys' star receiver didn't hold back on the team's 3-5 start, voicing his frustration with an expletive to reporters on Thursday.


Kate Middleton smiling at a royal engagement
Lifestyle

Kate Middleton's India tour wardrobe gets a modern update 10 years on

Kylie Jenner
Celebrity

Kylie Jenner's vintage Cavalli Governors Awards gown lost its racy cutout

A classic peanut butter and jelly sandwich
Food

Chex turned the PB&J sandwich into breakfast cereal, and fans are stocking up

Taylor Swift at the 2024 Golden Globes
Entertainment

Taylor Swift jokes she's 'zero for eight' in song of the year ahead of 2027 Grammys

Patrick Mahomes preparing to snap the ball for the Kansas City Chiefs
Sport

Patrick Mahomes threw 5 TDs on a UCL elbow injury - Rex Ryan is in awe

Hailey Bieber at the WWD Style Awards 2026
Lifestyle

Hailey Bieber's face masks decoded: salmon DNA sheets, caffeine and LED

Matt Damon smiling at an event
Celebrity

Matt Damon: Ben Affleck raved about Robert Pattinson's 'Odyssey' role

Patrick Schwarzenegger posing on the red carpet at the Venice Film Festival
Food

Patrick Schwarzenegger says a frosted glass is what makes a great martini

Pedro Pascal with Bella Ramsey at SXSW 2025
Entertainment

Pedro Pascal says 'Behemoth!' gave him 'tremendous hope' - and nobody made money

Jagged limestone peaks of the Accursed Mountains in the Albanian Alps
Travel

The Peaks of the Balkans trail now draws 43,000 hikers a year - how to walk it

Christian Pulisic in a US men's national team jersey during a match against Belgium
Sport

Pulisic and Balogun both score in 6-0 US rout of Haiti as Pochettino nears exit

Florence Pugh posing on the red carpet at the 2024 Toronto International Film Festival
Lifestyle

Florence Pugh's sculptural sleeves rose above her head at the East of Eden event

Hugh Jackman performing on stage
Celebrity

Hugh Jackman and Sutton Foster share a towel on Bondi Beach

Exterior of a Taco Bell fast food restaurant in Jupiter, Florida
Food

Taco Bell's FLAMIN' HOT Mini Taco Salad underdelivers - the burrito brings heat

Ryan Gosling at a public event
Entertainment

Joel Negron cut Project Hail Mary from 700 hours of footage into a 2.5-hour film

Green alpine valley with mountain peaks in the Austrian Alps
Travel

Hotel Nesslerhof: Austria's 'natural happiness hotel' where naked is the norm

Miami Hurricanes basketball players in action during a game
Sport

Brent Bland hits 8 threes off the bench as No. 17 Miami sets a school 3-point record

Dua Lipa during a 2021 VOA interview
Lifestyle

Dua Lipa debuts Charlotte Simone's shaggy-collared coat ahead of Winter Drop 2

Malin Akerman smiling during a visit to the TODAY show
Celebrity

Malin Akerman blows a kiss at 'The Hunting Wives' Season 2 premiere in LA

Flatbread resting on a kitchen counter
Food

Taylor Ann Spencer tried GBBO's 'worst technical' flatbread - and lost to a smoking pan