Ina Garten says Thanksgiving beats Christmas - and she visibly cringes at marshmallow yams

Celebrity & Entertainment journalist
Ina Garten, the Barefoot Contessa, speaking at the Montclair Film Festival in 2024
Ina Garten at Montclair Film Festival 2024 Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 2.0

Ina Garten has settled the holiday debate, and there is no contest for her. On the November 18 episode of her Happy Hour with Ina Garten podcast, the Barefoot Contessa called Thanksgiving the superior holiday because of how calm and food-focused the whole day is.

"Thanksgiving is just quiet. It's all that one day and it's all about the food," she told guest Rose Byrne, adding that Christmas comes loaded with gifts, parties, and a whole lot of extra pressure.

The conversation started when Garten asked Byrne, an Australian actress, about her first Thanksgiving in the United States. Byrne recalled a Friendsgiving potluck where everyone brought a dish, and Garten immediately wanted to know if the meal was organized in advance "or if everyone just showed up with string beans."

The dish that made Ina grimace

Things got funnier when Byrne mentioned candied yams topped with marshmallows, which she found "pretty weird." Garten visibly grimaced, chuckled, and described the dish as "very American."

Judging by that reaction, marshmallow-topped yams will not be appearing at her next dinner party.

Garten's Thanksgiving enthusiasm also extends to the wine. Last year she shared her favorite bottles to pour with the meal, including Morgon, a lighter French red from Beaujolais, and white Burgundies like Meursault or Montrachet alongside the turkey. For an American option she favors a Sonoma Valley Pinot Noir.

More in the section Food

Ciara performing on stage at the TODAY Show Concert Series
Food

Ciara's holiday cooking rule: 'You better not burn no turkey'

The Grammy winner calls a burnt Christmas bird a 'culinary crime' - and warns there's no backup if you mess it up.

A Popeyes classic chicken sandwich with a breaded fillet, pickles and mayo on a brioche bun
Food

Popeyes beats Chick-fil-A in chicken sandwich taste test, its second straight win

A Delish taste test crowns Popeyes' Classic Chicken Sandwich over Chick-fil-A's Original, giving Popeyes a second straight win after beating KFC.

A dessert bowl of vanilla pudding topped with whipped cream and fresh raspberries
Food

Whipped cream at home: the one trick is beating with a side-to-side whisk

Cold cream, a bigger bowl than you think, and a side-to-side whisk - not circles - is all it takes for perfect peaks.

A baking dish of lasagna with brown cheese and meat sauce, fresh from the oven
Food

Trader Joe's frozen lasagna beat Rao's and Stouffer's in a blind taste test

Bon Appetit cooked nine store-bought meat lasagnas from frozen. Here's which ones tasters would actually keep in the freezer.

A mug of rich hot chocolate topped with marshmallows and cream
Food

Glace's viral NYC hot chocolate is now a $20 at-home mix

The TikTok-famous S'mores Hot Chocolate from NYC's Glace now ships nationwide as a six-sachet mix for $19.99.

A classic peanut butter and jelly sandwich
Food

Chex turned the PB&J sandwich into breakfast cereal, and fans are stocking up

General Mills is launching Chex Peanut Butter & Jelly Cereal, mixing strawberry- and peanut butter-flavored pieces in one box.

Patrick Schwarzenegger posing on the red carpet at the Venice Film Festival
Food

Patrick Schwarzenegger says a frosted glass is what makes a great martini

After three years with Ketel One, the White Lotus actor says one small detail - a chilled glass - is what separates a good martini from a great one.

Exterior of a Taco Bell fast food restaurant in Jupiter, Florida
Food

Taco Bell's FLAMIN' HOT Mini Taco Salad underdelivers - the burrito brings heat

Taco Bell's new $2.49 Mini Taco Salad barely registers as spicy, but the returning $5.49 Grilled Cheese Burrito delivers a real FLAMIN' HOT kick.

Flatbread resting on a kitchen counter
Food

Taylor Ann Spencer tried GBBO's 'worst technical' flatbread - and lost to a smoking pan

Delish's Taylor Ann Spencer recreated the GBBO blue cheese and roasted grape flatbread under the show's 60-minute timer - and finished with three raw ones.

A McDonald's apple pie in its cardboard sleeve
Food

McDonald's Holiday Pie is back for 2026 with custard and rainbow sprinkles

McDonald's Holiday Pie is back at select U.S. restaurants for the 2026 season, loaded with custard, sugar glaze and rainbow sprinkles.


Miley Cyrus smiling during an appearance on the Today show
Entertainment

Miley Cyrus and Maxx Morando share first black-and-white wedding photos

Carlos Alcaraz holding a tennis racket at the 2026 US Open
Sport

Carlos Alcaraz sets up ATP Finals final vs Alexander Zverev after Shelton scare

Jennifer Lawrence speaking at Tulane University in 2018
Celebrity

Jennifer Lawrence reacts to Taylor Swift and Karlie Kloss reunion: 'Elder abuse'

Milford Sound fjord surrounded by mountain peaks in Fiordland National Park, New Zealand
Travel

Milford Sound's $383 business-class tour adds a five-course menu

Hailey Bieber posing at the WWD Style Awards in 2026
Lifestyle

Hailey Bieber's coat streak: sold-out Philo, 1998 Yohji Yamamoto, fur opera coat

Ciara performing on stage at the TODAY Show Concert Series
Food

Ciara's holiday cooking rule: 'You better not burn no turkey'

Ariana Grande smiling at a press event
Entertainment

Ariana Grande reveals the wildest place she's heard her own song: a bikini wax

Serena Williams mid-serve during a Wimbledon match
Sport

Billie Jean King told a 6-year-old Serena Williams to never let anyone change her serve

Jennifer Lopez posing on a red carpet in an elegant gown
Celebrity

Jennifer Lopez wears sheer lace Dolce & Gabbana gown and a 100-carat yellow diamond

View of Porto's riverside and the Dom Luis I bridge from Vila Nova de Gaia, Portugal
Travel

TAP Air Portugal adds Washington Dulles-to-Porto nonstops from March 30

Selena Gomez at the 2024 Toronto International Film Festival
Lifestyle

Selena Gomez's black velvet Khaite suit is the holiday party outfit to copy

A Popeyes classic chicken sandwich with a breaded fillet, pickles and mayo on a brioche bun
Food

Popeyes beats Chick-fil-A in chicken sandwich taste test, its second straight win

Olivia Rodrigo singing on stage at Lollapalooza Argentina in 2025
Entertainment

Olivia Rodrigo's 'Stupid Song' jumps to No. 1 on Billboard's Pop Airplay chart

Dolly Parton in a 1970 RCA Records press portrait
Celebrity

Dolly Parton's niece wore a dress made for her unfinished video at the CMA Awards

Durdle Door limestone arch and grassy cliffs at West Lulworth, Dorset
Travel

How to walk England's South West Coast Path solo in 3 days - no tent

Patrick Mahomes in a Kansas City Chiefs uniform during a game
Sport

Chiefs GM Brett Veach: Patrick Mahomes' quick knee recovery 'didn't surprise' him

Lady Gaga performing on stage during the Joanne World Tour
Lifestyle

Lady Gaga left yoga in Saint Laurent slingbacks - and carried bone broth

A dessert bowl of vanilla pudding topped with whipped cream and fresh raspberries
Food

Whipped cream at home: the one trick is beating with a side-to-side whisk

Brad Pitt smiling
Entertainment

Brad Pitt's Cliff Booth returns in a Tarantino-Fincher hangout movie critics are loving

Hotel Cipriani Venice with boats moored at its waterfront berth
Travel

Dior opens its first Venice spa at Hotel Cipriani, with a 90-minute Mascarade facial