Trader Joe's frozen lasagna beat Rao's and Stouffer's in a blind taste test
Frozen lasagna is the dinner you make when you can't face the layering. So Bon Appetit decided to find out which one actually holds together - and it turns out the winner is a fan-favorite private-label buy, not a big brand.
For the test, tasters cooked nine store-bought meat lasagnas from frozen, keeping every brand name covered. Three rose above the rest: Trader Joe's for closest-to-homemade, Rao's for the best single serving, and Marie Callender's as a dependable backup.
The winner: Trader Joe's
Trader Giotto's Family Style Meat Lasagna (32 oz, about $8) restored the testers' faith after an early series of disappointments. The noodles had a fresh bounce, the four cheeses - ricotta, mozzarella, Romano and Parmesan - each held their own, and fennel, oregano and basil gave the sauce a bright, homemade feel.
"There's a whole tomato!" senior editor Kelsey Jane Youngman exclaimed after finding a chunk of diced tomato in her sample. Evenly distributed ground beef and pork sealed the deal.
The rest of the field
If you're cooking for one, the 9-oz Rao's Made for Home Meat Lasagna (about $6) won praise for its sturdy structure and umami-rich sauce - no soupy, floppy layers here. Marie Callender's was a solid third, with a slightly sweet-tangy sauce and springy pasta sheets.
Stouffer's Classic divided the room: some loved the tender meat sauce, while others found it overly sweet with "dusty" herbs. Beecher's was watery and sour, Great Value's meat came out grainy, and Michael Angelo's noodles were flimsy and overcooked.