J.K. Rowling was accused of anti-Semitism because of goblins running Gringotts Bank

Juliette Morgan
J.K. Rowling was accused of anti-Semitism because of goblins running Gringotts Bank

American comedian and TV presenter Jon Stewart accused writer J.K. Rowling of anti-Semitism — in the last episode of his podcast The Problem With Jon Stewart, he drew attention to the fact that in the Harry Potter books, goblins running the Gringotts bank are similar in description to caricature Jews.

When I talk to people, I often ask them: "Have you watched the Harry Potter movies? Have you seen the scenes at Gringotts Bank? Do you know who these guys who run the bank are? Jews!"

Stewart pointed out that when he showed his interlocutors an illustration from the 1903 anti-Semitic book "Protocols of the Elders of Zion", they often believed that it depicted a scene from "Harry Potter".

And they're like, "Oh, it's a picture from a Harry Potter book!". And you say to them: "No, this is a caricature of a Jew from anti-Semitic literature." <...> This is the world of magic and sorcery. There you can fly dragons, get an owl as a pet. But who will run the bank? Jews. Unless we make their teeth sharper.

The 59-year-old comedian added that he did not expect such indifference from society to what he himself immediately drew attention to.

When I saw it on the screen, I thought that people would be outraged that everyone would say: "Oh shit, did she really do that, in the world of magic, to force Jews to run a fucking underground bank." And everyone waved them off, they say, they're just magicians. It was so weird.

J.K. Rowling has been accused of anti-Semitism before because of the Gringotts goblins. But there were also those who spoke out in her defense. So, the writer Dan Kahan in an article for PopDust noticed: 

The goblins of Gringotts really look like stereotypical Jews in the minds of anti-Semites. But surely Rowling didn't do it intentionally. In addition, there are many borrowings from folklore and other fantasy stories in her Harry Potter books. So the anti-Semitic features of goblins rather refer to how bankers were portrayed in fantasy. It just so happened that they were probably inspired by anti-Jewish propaganda.

At the moment, the writer is also at the center of a scandal due to accusations of transphobia, which is why she was not invited to shoot in the special episode "Harry Potter 20 years later: Return to Hogwarts".

More in the section Celebrity

A rare portrait of Princess Diana graces the cover of Tatler
Celebrity

A rare portrait of Princess Diana graces the cover of Tatler

The photo was taken in 1988.

Beyoncé and her daughter presented a film about the singer's Renaissance tour
Celebrity

Beyoncé and her daughter presented a film about the singer's Renaissance tour

Beyonce appeared with her daughter at the premiere of the film in honor of her Renaissance tour.

Matthew Williams steps down as creative director of Givenchy
Celebrity

Matthew Williams steps down as creative director of Givenchy

The fashion house did not renew the contract with the designer.

"Women over fifty don't know themselves." Jodie Foster on age, appearance, criticism and the downsides of fame
Celebrity

"Women over fifty don't know themselves." Jodie Foster on age, appearance, criticism and the downsides of fame

Jodie Foster became one of the main characters in the new issue of Elle: the actress starred in an uncharacteristically candid photo shoot and gave an interview.

"I want to raise men who are not like my exes." Megan Fox talks about raising her sons
Celebrity

"I want to raise men who are not like my exes." Megan Fox talks about raising her sons

Previously, she wrote a book of poems in which she talked about difficult relationships.

Plus-size models were offended by Emily Ratajkowski's photo and accused her of fatphobia
Celebrity

Plus-size models were offended by Emily Ratajkowski's photo and accused her of fatphobia

The model's photo shoot is being discussed online.

Yulia Peresild and Mikhail Troynik secretly got married
Celebrity

Yulia Peresild and Mikhail Troynik secretly got married

Information has appeared online about the secret wedding of Yulia Peresild and Mikhail Troynik.

Rumors about Prince William's affair with Marchioness Rose Hanbury are again being discussed in the media
Celebrity

Rumors about Prince William's affair with Marchioness Rose Hanbury are again being discussed in the media

Prince William's alleged affair with his wife Catherine's friend, Marchioness Rose of Hanbury, is once again being discussed.

"The demons of the mind are in my head." Elon Musk said that at the age of 12 he encountered depression and wanted to commit suicide
Celebrity

"The demons of the mind are in my head." Elon Musk said that at the age of 12 he encountered depression and wanted to commit suicide

According to him, a “fountain of ideas” constantly passes through him. and this cannot be called pleasant.

Sharon Stone, Diane Kruger and Johnny Depp at the Saudi Arabia Film Festival
Celebrity

Sharon Stone, Diane Kruger and Johnny Depp at the Saudi Arabia Film Festival

Sharon Stone, Diane Kruger, Alessandra Ambrosio, Michelle Williams and Johnny Depp appeared at the opening of the film festival in Saudi Arabia.


A rare portrait of Princess Diana graces the cover of Tatler
Celebrity

A rare portrait of Princess Diana graces the cover of Tatler

Beyoncé and her daughter presented a film about the singer's Renaissance tour
Celebrity

Beyoncé and her daughter presented a film about the singer's Renaissance tour

Matthew Williams steps down as creative director of Givenchy
Celebrity

Matthew Williams steps down as creative director of Givenchy

"Women over fifty don't know themselves." Jodie Foster on age, appearance, criticism and the downsides of fame
Celebrity

"Women over fifty don't know themselves." Jodie Foster on age, appearance, criticism and the downsides of fame

"I want to raise men who are not like my exes." Megan Fox talks about raising her sons
Celebrity

"I want to raise men who are not like my exes." Megan Fox talks about raising her sons

Plus-size models were offended by Emily Ratajkowski's photo and accused her of fatphobia
Celebrity

Plus-size models were offended by Emily Ratajkowski's photo and accused her of fatphobia

Yulia Peresild and Mikhail Troynik secretly got married
Celebrity

Yulia Peresild and Mikhail Troynik secretly got married

Rumors about Prince William's affair with Marchioness Rose Hanbury are again being discussed in the media
Celebrity

Rumors about Prince William's affair with Marchioness Rose Hanbury are again being discussed in the media

"The demons of the mind are in my head." Elon Musk said that at the age of 12 he encountered depression and wanted to commit suicide
Celebrity

"The demons of the mind are in my head." Elon Musk said that at the age of 12 he encountered depression and wanted to commit suicide

Sharon Stone, Diane Kruger and Johnny Depp at the Saudi Arabia Film Festival
Celebrity

Sharon Stone, Diane Kruger and Johnny Depp at the Saudi Arabia Film Festival

"Still my best friend." Laysan Utyasheva about Irina Viner’s criticism of her
Celebrity

"Still my best friend." Laysan Utyasheva about Irina Viner’s criticism of her

"It was a difficult decision." Paris Hilton explained why her two children were born to a surrogate mother
Celebrity

"It was a difficult decision." Paris Hilton explained why her two children were born to a surrogate mother

Kate Middleton has made her first public appearance since she was named among those who made racist comments about Meghan Markle's son
Celebrity

Kate Middleton has made her first public appearance since she was named among those who made racist comments about Meghan Markle's son

Rosie Huntington-Whiteley showed how she spends time with Jason Statham in Abu Dhabi
Celebrity

Rosie Huntington-Whiteley showed how she spends time with Jason Statham in Abu Dhabi

Julia Roberts in mini-shorts and "fluffy" pumps at the film premiere
Celebrity

Julia Roberts in mini-shorts and "fluffy" pumps at the film premiere

"Women become sexier as they age." Jennifer Lopez stripped naked for a new photo shoot
Celebrity

"Women become sexier as they age." Jennifer Lopez stripped naked for a new photo shoot

High relationship: Gwyneth Paltrow published a photo in which she holds the hand of her ex-husband's girlfriend Dakota Johnson
Celebrity

High relationship: Gwyneth Paltrow published a photo in which she holds the hand of her ex-husband's girlfriend Dakota Johnson

“Something is happening beyond understanding.” Britney Spears said fans are right to worry about her
Celebrity

“Something is happening beyond understanding.” Britney Spears said fans are right to worry about her

Fedor Smolov dedicated a goal to his newborn daughter and declassified her name
Celebrity

Fedor Smolov dedicated a goal to his newborn daughter and declassified her name

Jennifer Lopez and Ben Affleck kiss while walking in Los Angeles
Celebrity

Jennifer Lopez and Ben Affleck kiss while walking in Los Angeles