J.K. Rowling was accused of anti-Semitism because of goblins running Gringotts Bank

Juliette Morgan
J.K. Rowling was accused of anti-Semitism because of goblins running Gringotts Bank

American comedian and TV presenter Jon Stewart accused writer J.K. Rowling of anti-Semitism — in the last episode of his podcast The Problem With Jon Stewart, he drew attention to the fact that in the Harry Potter books, goblins running the Gringotts bank are similar in description to caricature Jews.

When I talk to people, I often ask them: "Have you watched the Harry Potter movies? Have you seen the scenes at Gringotts Bank? Do you know who these guys who run the bank are? Jews!"

Stewart pointed out that when he showed his interlocutors an illustration from the 1903 anti-Semitic book "Protocols of the Elders of Zion", they often believed that it depicted a scene from "Harry Potter".

And they're like, "Oh, it's a picture from a Harry Potter book!". And you say to them: "No, this is a caricature of a Jew from anti-Semitic literature." <...> This is the world of magic and sorcery. There you can fly dragons, get an owl as a pet. But who will run the bank? Jews. Unless we make their teeth sharper.

The 59-year-old comedian added that he did not expect such indifference from society to what he himself immediately drew attention to.

When I saw it on the screen, I thought that people would be outraged that everyone would say: "Oh shit, did she really do that, in the world of magic, to force Jews to run a fucking underground bank." And everyone waved them off, they say, they're just magicians. It was so weird.

J.K. Rowling has been accused of anti-Semitism before because of the Gringotts goblins. But there were also those who spoke out in her defense. So, the writer Dan Kahan in an article for PopDust noticed: 

The goblins of Gringotts really look like stereotypical Jews in the minds of anti-Semites. But surely Rowling didn't do it intentionally. In addition, there are many borrowings from folklore and other fantasy stories in her Harry Potter books. So the anti-Semitic features of goblins rather refer to how bankers were portrayed in fantasy. It just so happened that they were probably inspired by anti-Jewish propaganda.

At the moment, the writer is also at the center of a scandal due to accusations of transphobia, which is why she was not invited to shoot in the special episode "Harry Potter 20 years later: Return to Hogwarts".

More in the section Celebrity

Ewan McGregor spoke about the difficult divorce and his daughter's reaction to his new family: "There was alienation"
Celebrity

Ewan McGregor spoke about the difficult divorce and his daughter's reaction to his new family: "There was alienation"

In an interview with British GQ, actor Ewan McGregor talked about how his views on parenting have changed with the appearance of his son, as...

"It's a shame, colleagues": Regina Todorenko denied the news about her childbirth and criticized the media
Celebrity

"It's a shame, colleagues": Regina Todorenko denied the news about her childbirth and criticized the media

Today, many Russian media outlets have released the news that Regina Todorenko and Vlad Topalov have become parents for the second time. Jou...

New footage from the shooting: Margot Robbie and Ryan Gosling on commercials in the images of Barbie and Ken
Celebrity

New footage from the shooting: Margot Robbie and Ryan Gosling on commercials in the images of Barbie and Ken

Footage continues to appear from the set of the movie "Barbie", where the world's most famous doll is played by Margot Robbie, and her boyfr...

In the style of Barbie and Ken: Megan Fox and Colson Baker in pink outfits attended the premiere in New York
Celebrity

In the style of Barbie and Ken: Megan Fox and Colson Baker in pink outfits attended the premiere in New York

The movie "Barbie" has not yet been released, but it seems to be already affecting fashion — Megan Fox in a Nensi Dojaka dress and Colson Ba...

Norwegian Princess Martha Louise for the first time commented on the bisexuality of her fiance — shaman Durek Verrett
Celebrity

Norwegian Princess Martha Louise for the first time commented on the bisexuality of her fiance — shaman Durek Verrett

Norwegian Princess Martha Louise, who recently got engaged to shaman Durek Verrett, spoke about her attitude to her fiance's bisexuality. Sh...

Disney, Netflix, Condé Nast, Meta* will pay for abortion trips to other states
Celebrity

Disney, Netflix, Condé Nast, Meta* will pay for abortion trips to other states

After the U.S. Supreme Court overturned the 1973 Roe v. Wade ruling that recognized abortion as a constitutional right, a wave of protests s...

Glavklub announced the cancellation of the performances of Manizhi, Anacondaz and the "Accident" due to pressure from government agencies: "Sorry, we tried"
Celebrity

Glavklub announced the cancellation of the performances of Manizhi, Anacondaz and the "Accident" due to pressure from government agencies: "Sorry, we tried"

Representatives of the Glavklub reported that they were forced to cancel the announced performances of Manizhi, Anacondaz and the Accident g...

A kiss with a girl on stage, a son on a backup dance — what did Madonna's performance in New York remember
Celebrity

A kiss with a girl on stage, a son on a backup dance — what did Madonna's performance in New York remember

The other day Madonna gave a concert in New York, dedicated to the celebration of Pride Month. Recall that in June, events are held in many...

Kate Middleton tried on a military uniform on the occasion of the Day of the Armed Forces of Great Britain
Celebrity

Kate Middleton tried on a military uniform on the occasion of the Day of the Armed Forces of Great Britain

Kate Middleton congratulated the British military on the Armed Forces Day, which is celebrated in the country on June 26. On the occasion of...

Ezra Miller was accused of kidnapping a mother with three children. He helped them escape from domestic violence
Celebrity

Ezra Miller was accused of kidnapping a mother with three children. He helped them escape from domestic violence

The star of "Fantastic Beasts" Ezra Miller found himself in the center of a new scandal: he was accused of sheltering a young mother with th...


Ewan McGregor spoke about the difficult divorce and his daughter's reaction to his new family: "There was alienation"
Celebrity

Ewan McGregor spoke about the difficult divorce and his daughter's reaction to his new family: "There was alienation"

"It's a shame, colleagues": Regina Todorenko denied the news about her childbirth and criticized the media
Celebrity

"It's a shame, colleagues": Regina Todorenko denied the news about her childbirth and criticized the media

New footage from the shooting: Margot Robbie and Ryan Gosling on commercials in the images of Barbie and Ken
Celebrity

New footage from the shooting: Margot Robbie and Ryan Gosling on commercials in the images of Barbie and Ken

In the style of Barbie and Ken: Megan Fox and Colson Baker in pink outfits attended the premiere in New York
Celebrity

In the style of Barbie and Ken: Megan Fox and Colson Baker in pink outfits attended the premiere in New York

Norwegian Princess Martha Louise for the first time commented on the bisexuality of her fiance — shaman Durek Verrett
Celebrity

Norwegian Princess Martha Louise for the first time commented on the bisexuality of her fiance — shaman Durek Verrett

Disney, Netflix, Condé Nast, Meta* will pay for abortion trips to other states
Celebrity

Disney, Netflix, Condé Nast, Meta* will pay for abortion trips to other states

Glavklub announced the cancellation of the performances of Manizhi, Anacondaz and the "Accident" due to pressure from government agencies: "Sorry, we tried"
Celebrity

Glavklub announced the cancellation of the performances of Manizhi, Anacondaz and the "Accident" due to pressure from government agencies: "Sorry, we tried"

A kiss with a girl on stage, a son on a backup dance — what did Madonna's performance in New York remember
Celebrity

A kiss with a girl on stage, a son on a backup dance — what did Madonna's performance in New York remember

Kate Middleton tried on a military uniform on the occasion of the Day of the Armed Forces of Great Britain
Celebrity

Kate Middleton tried on a military uniform on the occasion of the Day of the Armed Forces of Great Britain

Ezra Miller was accused of kidnapping a mother with three children. He helped them escape from domestic violence
Celebrity

Ezra Miller was accused of kidnapping a mother with three children. He helped them escape from domestic violence

Singer Adele was at the center of a scandal after she announced a new concert
Celebrity

Singer Adele was at the center of a scandal after she announced a new concert

Sharon Stone spoke about the experiences after unsuccessful pregnancies: "Women have to endure it alone and in secret, with a sense of failure"
Celebrity

Sharon Stone spoke about the experiences after unsuccessful pregnancies: "Women have to endure it alone and in secret, with a sense of failure"

Denise Richards started an account on OnlyFans after her daughter registered on the platform
Celebrity

Denise Richards started an account on OnlyFans after her daughter registered on the platform

Svetlana Bondarchuk condemned the party and escorts: "It's nicer to look at models than professional beauties from the Patriarchal"
Celebrity

Svetlana Bondarchuk condemned the party and escorts: "It's nicer to look at models than professional beauties from the Patriarchal"

Billie Eilish revealed that she used a double at the Coachella Festival: "Everyone thought it was me"
Celebrity

Billie Eilish revealed that she used a double at the Coachella Festival: "Everyone thought it was me"

The first official portrait of Kate Middleton and Prince William is presented
Celebrity

The first official portrait of Kate Middleton and Prince William is presented

Prince Albert II and Princess Charlene with their children visited Norway and kissed in public — despite rumors of problems in marriage
Celebrity

Prince Albert II and Princess Charlene with their children visited Norway and kissed in public — despite rumors of problems in marriage

The New York Times: Media mogul Rupert Murdoch and Jerry Hall are getting divorced
Celebrity

The New York Times: Media mogul Rupert Murdoch and Jerry Hall are getting divorced

Prince George held a cake sale to raise money for animal welfare
Celebrity

Prince George held a cake sale to raise money for animal welfare

Entertainment tonight: Kendall Jenner and Devin Booker Split after Two Years of Relationship
Celebrity

Entertainment tonight: Kendall Jenner and Devin Booker Split after Two Years of Relationship