Ina Garten's roast chicken flopped on a platter — one swap sold it out in 10 minutes

Celebrity & Entertainment journalist
Ina Garten smiling on stage at the Montclair Film Festival
Ina Garten at Montclair Film Festival Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 2.0

Ina Garten says one of the biggest lessons behind her cookbooks started with a roast chicken nobody wanted. On a recent episode of The Mel Robbins Podcast, the Barefoot Contessa founder looked back at the early store experiment that reshaped how she cooks and writes recipes.

Garten bought the tiny Westhampton specialty food store at 30 with zero experience running one, fresh from a career in nuclear energy policy in Washington, D.C. She doesn't see the pivot as random. "If you're cooking, you're testing things," she told Robbins. "But instead of ending up with, like, gibberellic acid, you end up with roast chicken. So which would you rather have?"

The learning curve hit immediately. Garten says she didn't know how to cash out a register, slice smoked salmon, or scale the 12 brownies she made for friends into 1,000 for customers. Her first day as owner left just $87 in the register, and husband Jeffrey did the math: "I don't think you're gonna make it here." By the end of the next day — a busy Friday before Memorial Day weekend — the store was completely cleaned out, and she and the previous owner stayed up all night making chocolate cake and chicken salad.

Simple food, not fancy food

The real lesson came from what was not selling. Garten assumed a Hamptons specialty shop called for fancy dishes, so she made veal with morels and displayed her roast chickens on a huge white platter surrounded by fresh herbs. Nobody wanted them. She moved those same chickens into little red-and-white checkered baskets — and they sold in 10 minutes.

Her takeaway? "People have elegant taste, but they don't want fancy food at home." Garten said the realization "totally informed all of my cookbooks," which she built around dependable recipes, beautiful photography, and ingredients you could actually find at the grocery store.

When Robbins asked for her favorite recipe, Garten skipped anything elaborate and picked a French apple tart with a thin buttery crust, sliced apples, butter, and sugar. "It's a very simple recipe," she said. "I just think it's just gorgeous."

More in the section Food

A Taco Bell restaurant in Sydney, Australia
Food

Taco Bell's Fire Piña Hot Dog uses a chalupa as the bun at Live Más Open

Taco Bell served a grilled-pineapple hot dog inside its signature chalupa flatbread at the Live Más Open, and fans who couldn't try it were horrified.

A Chick-fil-A fast food restaurant building with drive-thru
Food

Chick-fil-A's Chicken & Waffles ends Nov. 14 - but 3 cities get a bigger test menu

Chick-fil-A's nationwide Chicken & Waffles menu leaves on Nov. 14, but Tampa, Chicago and Raleigh start testing a bigger waffle sandwich lineup two days later.

A can of jellied cranberry sauce with sliced cranberry sauce discs on a plate
Food

Ocean Spray turned canned cranberry sauce into chocolate candy - $24.95 a box

Ocean Spray, Compartés and recipe developer Carolina Gelen have dipped jellied cranberry sauce in chocolate for a $24.95 limited-edition candy.

A bowl of Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal squares
Food

Dunkin' teams with General Mills on 3 coffee-flavored cereals for December

Three General Mills breakfast staples get a Dunkin' makeover this December, with no caffeine in the box.

Charcuterie board arranged with cheeses, cured meats, olives and vegetables
Food

Turkuterie: a Bosc pear becomes a turkey-shaped cheese board in 30 minutes

A halved Bosc pear with two clove eyes and a cheese-triangle beak turns a basic charcuterie board into a turkey-shaped Thanksgiving centerpiece.

Stanley Tucci at the Final Portrait premiere, Berlinale 2017
Food

Stanley Tucci's real holiday hack: a splash of San Pellegrino in your martini

The actor's family holiday tradition is charades with no score, no rules and kids who get mad if you guess too fast.

A serving of Stove Top boxed stuffing on a plate
Food

We tried 8 boxed stuffings - these 5 taste homemade enough to fool your guests

Delish tested eight boxed stuffings and only five made the cut, with Kinder's Brown Butter & Herbs fooling testers into thinking it was homemade.

A golden apple pie with a lattice crust
Food

The $70 apple pie baked in a paper bag is worth the hype, Delish editors say

Delish editors put the Elegant Farmer's famous Apple Pie in a Paper Bag to the test and the verdict was unanimous.

A serving of McDonald's French fries in a red carton
Food

McDonald's fries still beat all 10 fast food rivals in Delish taste test

Delish tried fries from 11 chains and the Golden Arches came out on top, with KFC and Burger King close behind.

A frosted Pop-Tarts toaster pastry on a plain background
Food

Pop-Tarts and Liquid Death team up for a Frosted Orange toaster pastry

The new limited-edition flavor, inspired by Liquid Death's orange soda sparkling water, hits retailers this November.


Ariana Grande posing at a Wicked promotional event
Lifestyle

Ariana Grande chopped six inches into a flipped bob - and fall followed

Kendall Jenner on the red carpet at the Venice Film Festival
Celebrity

Kendall Jenner and Jacob Elordi's cozy autumn coffee date in NYC - with a kiss

A Taco Bell restaurant in Sydney, Australia
Food

Taco Bell's Fire Piña Hot Dog uses a chalupa as the bun at Live Más Open

Florence Pugh posing at an event in 2026
Entertainment

Florence Pugh is done with 'bullshit' on set: 'Show up on time, don't be a misogynist'

Frost-covered trees and snow in Banff National Park in winter
Travel

Banff in winter is more than skiing: snowshoeing, sauna rituals and sleigh rides

Rihanna smiling at an event in 2019
Lifestyle

Rihanna's half-tucked shirt collar is the runway trick anyone can steal

Lewis Hamilton in Ferrari race overalls during 2025 Italian Grand Prix qualifying
Sport

Lewis Hamilton is catching Mercedes' flight home - Toto Wolff has a drink planned

Blake Lively smiling on a red carpet
Celebrity

Blake Lively wore Ryan Reynolds' $990 Thom Browne shirt - & shared her style rule

A Chick-fil-A fast food restaurant building with drive-thru
Food

Chick-fil-A's Chicken & Waffles ends Nov. 14 - but 3 cities get a bigger test menu

Harry Styles singing on stage during his Together, Together tour in Amsterdam
Entertainment

Harry Styles jogs MSG stairs and suits up as Pizza Rat in final Harryween clip

A river cruise ship sailing on the Nile near Luxor, Egypt
Travel

Viking's new Nile river ships reach temples other cruises skip - here's the 11-night tour

Kylie Jenner looking at the camera
Lifestyle

Kylie Jenner made her LACMA debut in a shimmering deer-spot gown - it's fawn girl fall

Houston Texans wide receiver Tank Dell
Sport

Tank Dell scores first TD in 687 days as Texans receiver completes comeback from torn knee

A collection of Taylor Swift memorabilia and album items
Celebrity

Taylor Swift and Karlie Kloss reunite in Chiefs VIP suite after years-long feud

A can of jellied cranberry sauce with sliced cranberry sauce discs on a plate
Food

Ocean Spray turned canned cranberry sauce into chocolate candy - $24.95 a box

Olivia Rodrigo performing on stage at Lollapalooza Argentina 2025
Entertainment

Olivia Rodrigo is back at No. 1 as Thriller jumps to its highest spot in 40 years

Red rock canyon vista at Dead Horse Point State Park in Utah
Travel

Utah's national parks after dark: scorpion hunts, moonlit kayaks and star hikes

Hands with matte black nail polish dotted with small white polka dots
Lifestyle

Hailey Bieber swaps glazed nails for glossy black - and it's fall's biggest manicure

Lionel Messi of Inter Miami in action during an MLS match
Sport

Messi sets up two as Inter Miami blow 3-0 lead but seal second in MLS

Prince William and Catherine, Princess of Wales, with Prince George
Celebrity

Prince William's blunt reason for splitting with Kate: 'I wanted to be sure'